Anyone that saw this on this list ( it would definetelly have cracked my top 5) and went to play it would have been very confused and probably would not have beeen able to appreciate it if they had not played the Penumbra series.īut to anyone who has played the Penumbra series (especially if you were one of the many, many, MANY people that were extremely dissapointed with Requiem) this is a must play. But the main reason is because it is based off another game series entirely and most of the plot revolves around events of the previous Penumbra games. First, because of the fact that although it is technically an Amnnesia mod, it really is it's own game both in terms of idea and quality. Now lets get into the top ten starting from number 10ĭespite this being an absoloutely brilliant mod, I decided to not include in on the list, and I did this for a few reasons. Gameplay: How well did the story flow? Was it paced properly? Grammer and Speech: Gramatical abominations? Voice acting? Bugs: Did glitches or bugs ruin this mod? Puzzles: Too easy? Too hard? Too bland? Originality: Did this story stand out with unique features or mechanics? Mapping: How nice and unique were the levels? Did they contribute positively or negatively to the atmosphere?

Did it work well with the atmosphere? Where they overused? How good were they?

Atmosphere: How much did the enviroment and ambiance contribute to the overall feel of the mod? Did it make me feel like anything could pop out at anytime? Plot: How interesting and well made is the story? I will also add a brief description of the mod to highlight any other really good or bad things in the mod (mostly good this is a top 10 after all ) PS: Score does not nessecarily determine the placement, its just an indication of how well rounded the mod is. I hope you enjoy this guide and find it helpful :D There will also be a link at the bottom of the page to the site where you can find all the mods on this list, as well as many other good ones.Įach mod will be rated based on 10 factors out of ten for a total score out of 100. My main criterias for evaluation are creativity, a story, and the amount of work put into the mod.

Feel free to message me if you would like to (politely) explain why a mod should be added to this list or another be removed (i'm always open to others opinions). Before you read this please take note that these are my PERSONAL choices and you may not agree with all of them, especially since there are so many amazing amnesia mods out there, making a definitive top ten is difficult, which is why at the bottom, you will find a list and very brief descriptions of some of my favorite mods that didn't make this list, as well as a list of the best mods strictly for certain elements.

Amnesia best custom stories